01 25 financial act plan benchmarks header
improvement
The Data-Informed Difference: Balancing Expertise and Insights
Healthcare is entering a new era as leaders integrate clinical expertise with data-driven insights. By identifying trends, leveraging benchmarks, and challenging assumptions, they are enhancing patient care and creating a more effective healthcare system.

Balancing Heart and Data in Healthcare Leadership 

Healthcare is fundamentally about caring for people. Many of our leaders come from clinical backgrounds where patient care, not data analysis, was the focus of their training. That deep commitment to helping others is what makes our organization exceptional—but sometimes it can also influence how we evaluate situations and make decisions. 

When Experience and Data Tell Different Stories 

Consider this common scenario: Your clinical teams are providing excellent care, you're hearing positive feedback, and patient interactions seem consistently strong. Then the Patient Experience survey data arrives with results that tell a different story. It’s a situation many of our leader’s face, and it highlights why we need both our healthcare expertise and solid data to guide our decisions. 

A Framework for Data-Informed Leadership 

Think of data analytics like a navigation system—it provides guidance while you remain in control of the journey. Here's an approach that has helped many leaders at U of U Health combine their healthcare expertise with data insights: 

1. Identify Patterns 

Using tools like the Patient Experience Weekly Comments Report can reveal trends that aren't immediately visible in day-to-day operations. Maybe wait times are consistently appearing in feedback, or patients are expressing concerns about care team communication. These patterns help focus improvement efforts where they'll have the most impact. 

2. Use Benchmarks Effectively 

In healthcare, we regularly use benchmarks—from quality metrics to financial performance indicators. Whether you're reviewing staff turnover, patient outcomes, or operational efficiency, benchmarks help gauge where you stand and where you can improve. They're particularly valuable when comparing performance across similar departments or peer institutions

Benchmarking at U of U Health: A Quick Guide 

Think of benchmarking as a compass for organizational performance. It helps us move beyond gut feelings to understand where we truly stand. By comparing our metrics against internal departments and external peers, we create a clear picture of our strengths and opportunities for growth. 

Key Benchmarking Resources: 

Curious to dive deeper? Visit our Data Literacy page to explore these resources and learn more about data-informed decision-making.

3. Consider Context 

Healthcare is complex, and context matters. Patient acuity, teaching responsibilities, staff experience levels—all these factors influence your metrics. Understanding this context helps interpret data accurately and identify meaningful opportunities for improvement. 

4. Test Your Assumptions 

Before implementing major changes: 

  • Pilot new approaches with a single team or shift 

  • Gather diverse perspectives from staff, patients, and colleagues 

  • Review data across different time periods and situations 

  • Challenge your initial interpretations by seeking alternative explanations 

Making Data Accessible 

We understand that diving into data analysis can feel daunting, especially when you're managing numerous clinical and operational priorities. That's why U of U Health has dedicated experts in Decision Support, Patient Experience, Finance, and System Quality and many other areas ready to partner with you. You don't need to become a data scientist—you just need to know how to leverage these resources. 

Moving Forward Together 

The most effective healthcare decisions happen when we combine our organizational expertise with meaningful data insights. It's about seeing the connections—understanding how staff engagement affects patient experience, or how process changes impact quality measures. Your experience and judgment are invaluable—data simply helps refine and support your decision-making process. 

Remember, this is a journey we're all on together at U of U Health. Our goal isn't to replace professional judgment with spreadsheets, but to enhance our natural strengths with insights that lead to better outcomes for our patients and teams. 

Contributors

Kirk Hughs

Director, Outpatient Services ENT, University of Utah Health

Casey Moore

Director, Budgets, University of Utah Health

Subscribe to our newsletter

Receive the latest insights in health care impact, improvement, leadership, resilience, and more.